Ask Rick: Glycol Run Around Loops | Why do we not use Ethylene Glycol in the USA?

Q.  Why do we not use Ethylene Glycol in the USA?

Konvekta Pumped Glycol Coil

A.  Great Question.  We use pumped glycol energy recovery systems all the time here in the United States.  Up until recently we have almost exclusively used Propylene Glycol.  Ethylene Glycol had not even been a choice. 

The biggest reason for this is that Ethylene Glycol is toxic.  If you drink a couple of ounces, you die.  During Prohibition this actually happened.  People drank just about anything they could distill, including ethyl alcohol.  People died,  and people remembered that. 

What the heck!  The main ingredient in the vast majority of automotive antifreeze on the market today is ethylene glycol.   It’s also in most of the wind shield washer fluids.  We’re either dripping it on our garage floor or spraying it all over our windshields,  so why not use ethylene glycol in our pumped glycol energy recovery systems?

Benefits of Ethylene Glycol Solutions:

  • higher heat transfer coefficient
  • better freeze point depression
  • higher surface tension, less leaks
  • about 10% more efficient than Propylene Glycol in pumped systems

 Because Ethylene Glycol is toxic it is more closely regulated than Propylene Glycol.  Still you have to spill hundreds of gallons before reporting.   The Environmental Protection Agency has a reportable quantity (RQ) for spills of 5,000 pounds (539 gal.).  That’s a huge spill. 

Ironically, even though ethylene glycol is listed due to its toxicity, the environmental harm caused by the product contaminating an ecological area is less than propylene glycol because its decomposition rate is faster by half.  Thereby having a far lower Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD) than propylene glycol.  So Ethylene Glycol is actually greener.

Konvekta Pumpd Glycol Pumping PackageFinally,  it’s worthwhile to point out that our friends in Europe and Canada only use Ethylene Glycol in their energy run around loops.  Propylene Glycol is not considered as an option.

At DAC Sales,  we are using Ethylene Glycol in nearly all of the systems that we design with Konvekta here in the United States.  Looks like it’s time for a change.

More questions on pumped glycol systems;  askRick?

Great information from Konvekta:  Ethylene vs. Propylene Glycol
Dow Chemical Paper: Ethylene vs. Propylene Glycol

Related Pumped Glycol Energy Recovery Blog Posts:
What’s so special about Konvekta?
Konvekta High Performance Heat Exchanger Coil


Field Erected Air Handling Units | 4 Good Reasons to Assemble an Air Handling Unit On-Site

In 20 years of business we have been involved in supplying nearly 100 Field Erected Air Handling Units.  They come in all shapes and sizes and are used in lots of different applications.    

Field Erected UnitHere are the top 4 reasons why field erected units make sense:

  1. They Fit –  It’s very typical that worn out air handling units exist in the bowels of a building.  They  cannot be replaced by a traditional factory built unit.  Site Assembled Units  are typically rigged through elevators, hallways and doorways.  This construction technique often allows for a larger unit to be built in place to increase capacity.
  2. They Fit Better –  Available mechanical space is maximized by incorporating existing columns, beams and bracing into unit design.  Units can be built to the full extent of the space. 
  3. They Cost Less – Yes,  believe it.  If you include unit, rigging and install cost, then field erected units usually cost less than factory built units.  
  4. They have Shorter Lead Times  –  Lead time for a site-assembled unit is always less than a factory built unit.  Lead times are reduced to the timing of the longest lead time item like fans or coils.  4 to 6 weeks is possible for a custom field erected unit.

Field Erected UnitAssembling the air handling unit in place provides a cost-effective installation of the preferred air handling system in the preferred location without additional project costs (like knocking down walls) or unacceptable technical sacrifices.

Field erected air handling units utilize the same high quality components used in factory assembled units.   Panels and extrusions that makeup the casing system, equipment sub-assemblies and structural unit base sections are factory fabricated exactly as for a factory assembled unit.   These pieces are sized and transported on skids to accommodate the rigging limitations of freight elevators, door sizes, hallways or low ceilings, miniField Erected Unitmizing the impact on existing structures.   Field erected units are final assembled under the direction of factory trained supervisors.

In the end it’s very difficult to distinguish a field erected unit from a factory built unit. 

More questions on field erected air handling units;  askRick

 

Field Erected UnitField Erected Unit

Ask Rick: Pumped Glycol Systems | Does Air in the Glycol impact performance?

Q.  I have some questions about pumped glycol systems.  What happens if all the entrapped air is not removed from the glycol?   Should a closed loop have auto bleed?

Konvekta Pumpd Glycol Pumping Package

A.   Air bubbles entrapped in the glycol circuit are very detrimental to the thermal performance of the energy recovery system.  It causes the heat transfer coefficient in the coil tubes to drop dramatically.   In fact, it doesn’t take a lot of air in the glycol circuit to get the thermal energy recovery reduced to less than the pumping energy, turning the energy recovery system in a net energy consumer.

The Konvekta system has several safeguards to insure this is not happening:

  1. The glycol pumps are equipped with air separators
  2. A sight-glass on the Hydronic Unit allows the operator to see whether air is in the glycol
  3. The controller will detect the reduced thermal performance and alert the operator to the problem

Also, according to good engineering practice, air vents are designed at the high points of the piping to allow de-airation if necessary.

Rudolf Zaengerle, Ph.D.
President, Konvekta USA Inc.
5 Independence Way, 3d Floor #95
Princeton, NJ 08540
Phone: 724 462 8207

More questions about Pumped Glycol Energy Recovery Systems,  askRick?

Related Posts:
Pumped Glycol Energy Recovery | What’s so special about Konvekta?
Pumped Glycol Energy Recovery | Konvekta High Performance Heat Exchanger Coil

Ask Rick: How does a high pressure atomizing humidifier work?

Q.  How does a high pressure atomizing humidifier work?

High Pressure Humidification Spray

A.   Atomizing humidifiers like the Carel humiFog systems utilize a high pressure (1,000 psi) pumping system to pressurize treated water and pump it to atomizing nozzles.  The nozzles then reduce the water jet into a very fine water droplet (10-20 microns).  Due to the fine droplet size the water can easily change its state into a vapor.  The energy required for this transformation in state is provided by the ambient air.

There is a decrease in temperature which may be useful in many applications (adiabatic transformation).

High Pressure Humidification GridA packaged control system controls the speed of the pump via a variable frequency drive and consequently the flow-rate of the pump.  The controller activates a series of solenoid valves that open only the nozzles that are necessary, allowing the system to always operate at the ideal pressure to atomize the water, across a wide range of flow-rates.

 

 

High Pressure Humidification Panel

For more information on High Pressure Humidifiers askRick?

Related Blog Posts:
Ask Rick:  What is adiabatic humidification?

Custom Air Handling Units | 5 Reasons to use All Aluminum Construction

5 reasons to use All Aluminum Construction for Custom Air Handling Units?

Lawrence Hospital - All Aluminum Air Enterprises Unit

Lawrence Hospital - Air Enterprises Unit All Aluminum Construction

  1. Aluminum provides excellent corrosion resistance without the need for paint.
    • Painting and galvanization can be scrapped off during transportation, rigging and assembly of the unit.
    • Rust and corrosion reduce the structural integrity of the unit.
  2. Low Weight –  Aluminum construction can reduce overall unit weight by as much as 40%.
    • Reduced Rigging Costs
    • Reduced structural support costs
  3. Longer life
    • Aluminum equipment has a more than 40 year life expectancy
    • Galvanized equipment has a 25 year life expectancy
  4. Less impact on the environment
    • Install one unit in forty years not TWO!
  5. Air Enterprises40 year non-corrosive Guarantee

 

Air Enterprises 20 yr. Unit Compare Air-Enterprises Site Bilt Unit

 

 

 

 

 

Post by Steve Shelley

For more information on Custom Air Handling Units,  askRick?

Project Snapshot: Millipore Research and Development | Energy Recovery Air Handling Unit

Project: Millipore R&D Building
Location: Bedford,  MA
Engineer: Parsons
Contractor: Turner Construction Company
Manufacturer: Strobic Air, Cambridgeport, Heat Pipe Technology
Equipment: Energy Recovery Air Handling Units
Size: (4) 30,000 CFM Units
DAC Sales Engineer: Jim Shiminski

 
Millipore-HRUProject Challenge:    
This was a new building project.  The engineer, owner and contractor were all looking to create a design that provided the maximum energy savings while meeting the Mass. Energy Code.  The preliminary design called for 4 separate 30,000 CFM Make-Up Air Handling Units (AHUs) and 2 each Strobic Air Exhaust Energy Recovery Units (ERU’s). The total system air side was 120,000 CFM.  The original design included a pumped glycol energy recovery loop connecting each AHU to respective ERUs.  We did a preliminary estimates and determined that the energy recovery effectiveness would be about 45% for this system.  After subtracting out pumping energy the net effectiveness was expected to be closer to 40%.

Solution:
In this case we proposed to combine both supply and exhaust into one unit.  Instead of pumped glycol energy recovery we designed a Heat Pipe from Heat Pipe Technology into each of the units.  The Energy Recovery Air Handling Units were each sized for 30,000 CFM on both the supply and exhaust side.  The major advantage of this system was that it incorporated the use of a heat pipe to recover 65% of the energy from the exhaust air stream.  The costs for the two proposals were comparable after including the piping costs into the pumped glycol solution. 

 

Result:
The revised design was a much easier install.  The resulting system is at least 50% more energy efficient.   The units are all aluminum construction.  The owner now has a passive energy recovery system that does not have to be maintained.  That is a huge plus.

For questions on Energy Recovery Air Handling Units,  askRick?

Related Blog Posts:
High Plume Dilution Fans | What is a High Plume Dilution Fan?

High Plume Dilution Fans | Online Selection For Lab Exhaust Fans

Ask Rick: Pumped Glycol Energy Recovery | Pressure Drop for Konvekta Coils?

Q.  What is a typical pressure drop across the Konvekta coils?

Konvekta Pumped Glycol CoilA.  The air pressure drop across the coils depends on several factors: number of rows, air face velocity, fin spacing and tube alignments. There is a trade-off between thermal efficiency and air pressure drop which will be one of the design considerations if we know the price of heat ($/MBTU) and the price of electricity (fan power). Typically, one can expect an air pressure drop in the range of 0.4″ to 0.7″.

Rudolf Zaengerle, Ph.D.
President, Konvekta USA Inc.
5 Independence Way, 3d Floor #95
Princeton, NJ 08540
Phone: 724 462 8207

More questions about Pumped Glycol Energy Recovery Systems,  askRick?

Ask Rick: Lab Exhaust Fans | Lab Exhaust Stack vs. Air Intake Location

Q.  The commissioning engineer has commented that the Heat Recovery Unit (HRU) does not meet the 25’ separation distance between the Intake hood and Exhaust Discharge requirement. 
I believe that our design with the effective plume height of 44’ and the fan discharge 16’ above the inlet of the intake hood is better than a fan 25’ away from an intake.  We know that plumes do not come straight down.  Do you have any comment regarding separation of air intakes from exhaust discharge or have you seen this type of issue before and provided helpful information?

BWH New StrobicsA.  We recognize the recommendation in ASHRAE Standard 170-2008 (the Ventilation of Healthcare Facilities) which calls for recommended distance offsets between exhaust stacks and air intakes (placing an exhaust discharge 25′ from an intake).  This recommendation serves as a very useful guide to engineers.  It’s language is seen in other standards and shared by local standards as well.

In practice it is not practical to use this recommendation when evaluating High Plume Dilution Fans,  like the Strobic Air Tri-Stack Fans.  The Tri-Stack Fan uses a patented nozzle design to maintain stack velocities while minimizing horsepower.  Increased stack velocities allow the fan to entrain outside air (up to 170% by volume).  Process air and entrained air combine to produce a significantly higher effective stack height (the physical height of the equipment plus the plume height.).  This stack height calculation is used by wind consultants and CFD dispersion models worldwide.  The ASHRAE Standard 170-2008 does not take this stack height calculation into account and therefore should not be applied to a High Plume Dilution Fan type  applications.

Millipore-HRUWith High Plume Dilution fans, like the Tri-Stack Fan,  we have found that the safest place to position a fan is in close proximity to the building intakes.  This insures that the diluted exhaust air will be driven up and away from the intakes.  We recommend that the fan discharge velocity be maintained at 3,000 FPM per ANZI Z9.5.

Strobic Air has hundreds of laboratory fans that are located less than 25′ from air intakes.  We have many of those here in New England.  In 26 years Strobic Air has never experienced a single instance of re-entrainment on a laboratory.

Further questions about Laboratory Exhaust Fans –  askRick?

Related Posts:
Ask Rick: Lab Exhaust Fans | What Standards to reference for Lab Exhaust Fan design?
High Plume Dilution Fans | What is a High Plume Dilution Fan?

Pumped Glycol Energy Recovery | Konvekta High Performance Heat Exchanger Coil

konvektaKonvekta is the only supplier of high efficiency pumped glycol run-around energy recovery systems in the world.  They have been in the business of pumped glycol energy recovery  since 1949.  That’s all they do.  Konvekta offers complete systems – high performance heat exchangers, energy recovery system controls and hydraulic assembly.

Konvekta Pumped Glycol CoilThe Konvekta coil design is unlike all others – it is truly a high performance heat exchanger.  Prior to using this coil we would select standard water coils for all pumped glycol applications.  They were the best choice we had.  

There are issues involved in selecting standard water coils for glycol heat recovery applications

  • Standard water coils always get selected for a degree day that is worst case scenario and never happens.  Standard coils are not optimized for the temperatures that they are actually working at.  
  • Standard water coils are generally 8 rows or greater so pressure drops are significant. 
  • Decreasing flow through a standard water coil with a variable frequency drive (which would optimize heat transfer) , is not possible.  As velocity of glycol slows and becomes partially or completely laminar, the heat transfer coefficient drops significantly. 
  • Bottom Line – Standard water coils are not designed for Pumped Glycol Energy Recovery Applications

 

Konvekta Coil - Dartmouth College Burke Hall

Konvekta Coil - Dartmouth College Burke Hall

Konvekta  High Efficiency Heat Exchanger

Features:

  • Fin-tube heat exchanger with header at both ends 
  • Optimized Fin Design – thick, flat, wide-spaced fins
  • Selected for optimal temperature performance range (not a single point)
  • Corrosion protected

Benefits

  • Almost pure counter-flow for highest energy transfer
  • Low Pressure Drop
  • Fin Design provides high heat-transfer factors
  • Dual Headers create a high glycol Reynolds number to assure turbulent flow under all operating conditions
  • Design offers a very small air-to-glycol approach temperature difference to maximize heat transfer
  • Entire depth of coil accessible for cleaning
Konvekta Coils - Dartmouth College Burke Hall

Konvekta Coils - Dartmouth College Burke Hall

The biggest design features that achieve these benefits are headers on both ends of the coil and thick, flat, wide-spaced fins.  This coil is typically  10% more efficient than a standard water coil when used in run-around energy recovery applications.

If you have more questions feel free to  askRick?

Related Posts:
Pumped Glycol Energy Recovery | What’s so special about Konvekta?

Ask Rick: Pumped Glycol Systems | Where are Konvekta Systems manufactured?

Project Snapshot: United Electric | Energy Improvements with VAV Diffusers

Project:United Electric
Energy Services Company:Bluestone Energy Services
Manufacturer:Acutherm
Equipment:“Therma-Fuser” VAV Diffusers
DAC Sales Engineer: David Goodman

United Electric | Acutherm Therma-Fuser UpgradeProject Highlights:
Prior Conditions: Most of the areas of the engineering, manufacturing, assembly, test, inspection and packaging areas were all being served by 2 large central Air Handling Units (AHUs) running constant volume.  Manufacturing equipment and machines located at the southern end of the building could never get enough cooling during warmer months.  At the same time some interior zones such as inspection area, where people work, were often cold.  While there was a Heating mode it was rarely used because the facility generated considerable interior heat load year round.

The VAV Solution:
Premium efficiency motors and Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs) had already been added but a means to distribute and modulate the conditioned air to the all open areas was needed.  Bluestone engineers worked with DAC Sales and Acutherm Engineers on a simple retrofit solution.  The fix was to replace the old constant volume diffusers with Acutherm VAV Therma-Fuser modules.  The VAV Therma-Fuser modules with built in space sensing United Electric | Acutherm Therma-Fuser Upgradeelements could automatically modulate to deliver the precise amount of conditioned air to the local area.  Being applied to an exposed duct system, the new Round Therma-Fuser ST model was chosen in most areas while some used standard 2 X 2 ST square units.

The Results:
Now the machinists state they are finally cool and comfortable.  The over-conditioned spaces are gone.  This results in energy savings at the AHUs and reduced chiller load. During partial load days the Therma-Fuser modules are near the field set minimum position at many locations.  This “back-up” of air in the duct increases SP which signals the VFD to back down thus saving on fan energy.

United Electric | Acutherm Therma-Fuser UpgradeUnited Electric | Acutherm Therma-Fuser UpgradeUnited Electric | Therma-Fuser Upgrade

 

 

 

A chiller replacement rounded out the project and utility rebates were included to United Electric for stepping up with an aggressive energy measure program.

To learn more about Acutherm Therma-Fusers contact  David Goodman

Related Blog Posts:
Energy Saving VAV Diffusers | 6 Options for Building Automation Systems

VAV Diffusers | New clever design for the Therma-Fuser.